In short, if an action by management will cause a change in working conditions, it is likely that bargaining. A discussion is presented about various categories and incidences of contract concessions and union gains in the negotiation of union worker contracts. This paper examines the european lowcost airline industry by analysing how the rise of lowcost carriers lccs has influenced the relationship between airlines and airports. The new collective bargaining is defined, and a distinction is drawn between conventional collective bargaining and concession bargaining. This kind of bargaining takes place mainly when there is a recession condition in the market. The issue of concession bargaining between employers and unions. In contrast, in britain, it has been little discussed, although considerable media attention has been given to the case of the hyster forklift truck factory in scotland where management. In an attempt to identify a specific concession, bargaining game theory was employed. This kind of bargaining takes place mainly when there is. The author discusses the legal and practical differences between concession bar aining during the term of a collective bargaining agreement and at contract termination. Policymaking has been studied from a variety of conceptual perspectives. Relationships between concession bargaining and labor. This paper focuses on the conceptual implications of a study which applied that approach to a longitudinal investigation of the. Concession bargaining law and legal definition concession bargaining is a term used in labor law.
It seeks to provide practical advice and ideas to employers either bargaining for the first. The author presents a definition of cumulative excess return and results of regression analysis. The analysis suggests that union solidarity, union leader credibility, and union effectiveness have been. Essentials of negotiation 6th edition test bank lewicki. Finally, the evidence suggests that firmspecific sources of risk can explain, in part, not only the magnitude of the concession effects but also the probability that concession bargaining will occur. Chapter 02 strategy and tactics of distributive bargaining. On the other hand, concession bargaining does not seem to have reallocated business risk between shareholders and labor.
It is a kind of collective bargaining in which the trade unions surrender or give back previously gained improvements in pay and conditions in exchange for some form of job security. The following is an article on the history and evolution of concession bargaining in the us that is perhaps appropriate this labor day 2011. Although the causes for the upsurge in concession bargaining in the 1980s seem apparent, such. Distributive bargaining is basically a competition over who is going to get the most of a.
Concession bargaining how not to in the case of a business that is profitable, there is absolutely no reason for concession bargaining. The author discusses the legal and practical differences between concession bargaining during the term of a collective bargaining agreement and at contract termination, examines the financial disclosure requirement which frequently arises, and analyzes the recent nlrb and court decisions which have a significant impact on this area of the law. This analysis of bargaining settlements in 198283 shows that, on average, shareholders in those firms that negotiated concessionary settlements enjoyed an 8 to 10 percent increase in the value of their holdings. Concession bargaining and the national economy rakuten kobo. Concession bargaining is shaped more by the employers ability to pay than by the other factors brought up at the bargaining table such as changes in the cost of living or labor productivity. Publicly funded infrastructure is a necessary precondition for any business, and utilization charges are an important cost issue for firms, especially in the transportation industry. Concession bargaining, journal of conflict resolution, peace science society international, vol. The characteristics of concession bargaining relating to management behavior, information disclosure, intraunion activity. Concession bargaining something old but also something new. Kaufman and jorge martinezvazquez the authors of this paper use the median voter model to predict the patterns of rankandfile voting on wage concessions in a multiplant. Employers, trade unions and concession bargaining in the. The bargaining range is defined by all of the above. Concession bargaining law and legal definition uslegal, inc. What action can be taken after the first round of offers.
Read concession bargaining and the national economy by peter cappelli available from rakuten kobo. The simulation produced a range of concession period for the private sector and government to negotiate. The author interprets this result to mean not that the value of the firm increased, but rather that concessions enlarged the shareholders portion of the firms value at the expense. Mckersie and others published concession bargaining find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Impacts and implications article pdf available in journal of labor research 62. A twopersons bargaining problem often consists of initially incompatible demands that can be unilaterally reduced by sequential concessions. Concession bargaining is a development that has come to the fore as the pace of economic change has accelerated. One important theme in the literature on concession bargaining, however, is that unions usually seek.
Psychological and biological foundations of time preference, journal of the european economic association, mit press, vol. Unreliable concessions in static and dynamic bargaining. You will receive a formal invitation shortly, but we encourage you to mark your calendars and save the date. Collective bargaining and fair conditions of employment are synonymous. The author hypothesizes that this pattern resulted from interplant differences in the likelihood of layoffs or shutdowns, measured by factors such as plant age and size, relative wage level, and nature of product. Jan 07, 2014 concession bargaining at the crossroads by jack rasmus, 2011 the history of collective bargaining since the second world war has consisted of several stages or phases. Concession bargaining will be a key topic and we will address the issue in greater depth at that time. Collective bargaining from the 1960s was characterized by. This guide provides a basic introduction to collective bargaining. Concession bargaining an experimental comparison of.
Provisions such as this serve as an express limitation on an employers right to reduce force the parties in this case met and exchanged proposals over the impact of the employers decision to lay off employees. The parties collective bargaining agreement contained a minimum staffing provision. Plantlevel concession bargaining peter cappelli, 1985. In 1981 negotiations, about onethird of the plants in each industry engaged in concession bargaining and the others did not. The characteristics of concession bargaining relating to management behavior, information disclosure, intraunion activity, and union member attitudes are formulated and briefly described, followed by an exploration of the impact of the experience on and the implications for unions. In the united states, the phenomenon of concession bargaining, whereby management seeks to obtain wage freezes or actual cuts in wages, is being widely discussed by both researchers and practitioners. Sometimes, these concession dynamics unravel through the sequence of offers and counteroffers that. Moreover, compulsory concessions weaken the bargaining position of the proposer, who eventually gets significantly less. Pea collective bargaining guide 3 prebargaining research, election of bargaining committee, consultation and bargaining survey, develop proposals, serve notice to bargain. Management rights and impact bargaining 2010mmpa lrseminar. Richardson collective bargaining takes place when a number of work people enter into a negotiation as a bargaining unit with an employer or group of employers with the object of reaching an agreement on the conditions of the employment of the work people. The results of concession bargaining over the last two decades should stand as proof that concessions do not benefit workers. In proceedings of the thirtyfifth annual meeting of the industrial relations research association. Download fulltext pdf concession bargaining and unions.
The political bargaining model, used in conjunction with the broader systems framework, constitutes a familiar approach to research regarding education policymaking at the state level. Finally, although concessions significantly improve the likelihood of an agreement compared to standard ultimatum game experiments, the longer negotiation horizon five attempts instead of three delays the agreement without. Interpreting current developments in collective bargaining and industrial relations. We consider a demand game with the following additional ingredients. The article reports on a study which measured the indirect impact of union gains or concession bargaining on the economic interests of firms. Granting a longer but reasonable concession period is also one way of ensuring that the government is protecting the interest of the private sector, thus, giving more confidence to the private. Employers now act and unions react, rather than the other way around. A concession is a proposal that takes away a previously negotiated term that was of. Mills, 1983, we know little about the effects of such concessions on the balance of power between the parties.
Although they usually are seen as unfolding in time, concessions can also be studied in normal form or by conditioning only on failure of earlier agreement attempts. Bargaining game theory was employed in an attempt to find a specific concession period. We experimentally compare three protocols of concession bargaining, the normal form or static one, the one where concessions only. Bargaining rules free download as powerpoint presentation. The new collective bargaining gary chaison springer.
Sloan school of management, massachusetts institute of technology. Concession bargaining is the mirror image of conventional collective bargaining as employers act and unions react, rather than the reverse. Pdf concession bargaining an experimental comparison. Employers, trade unions and concession bargaining in the irish. In a 2 x 2 x 2 factorial design we distinguish between reliable and unreliable concessions, between a static and dynamic settings and between symmetric and asymmetric initial demands. Article information, pdf download for employers, trade unions and. It briefly traces how concession bargaining at the shop level has, since the late 1970s, evolved, transitioned recently to the public sector, and now is morphing into an attack on.
We test experimentally whether dynamic interaction is crucial for concession bargaining. In our complete information bargaining experiments, two parties with asymmetric conflict payoffs try to agree how to share a commonly known pie by bargaining over a finite number of successive trials. Two seemingly contradictory hypotheses about concessionmaking were considered. This paper presents a new noncooperative approach to multilateral bargaining. In concession bargaining unions give back to the management something it has gained from the management previously like pay rises, work practices, good working conditions and similar other things in return for job security. Collective bargaining in public educationby craig curry edad 587522 summer 2. To demonstrate the applicability of the proposed methodology, two buildoperatetransfer bot road projects in the philippines were used as case studies. Concession bargaining thomas miner during the past two years, few events in the field of industrial relations have generated as much media coverage and scholarly discussion2as the subject of concession bargaining.
Reasonable concession period for buildoperatetransfer. The collective bargaining of the past decade can be characterized as ultraconcession bargaining because it is an intense and selfperpetuating deviation from earlier concession bargaining. Although the causes for the upsurge in concession bargaining in. From concession bargaining to broad workplace solidarity. The two waves of concession bargaining the first in the. Two seemingly contradictory hypotheses about concession making were considered. Request pdf employers, trade unions and concession bargaining in the irish recession the issue of concession bargaining between employers and unions during the great recession has received. X has been added to states who have abolished bargaining rights since then. The collective bargaining system in the united states core. The collective bargaining of the past decade can be characterized as ultra concession bargaining because it is an intense and selfperpetuating deviation from earlier concession bargaining. May 19, 2012 concession bargaining is the mirror image of conventional collective bargaining as employers act and unions react, rather than the reverse.
219 428 1535 513 232 1268 315 1486 688 1444 1247 1161 104 1199 1642 313 1566 363 567 33 791 396 346 12 650 262 1226 362